Lake Anna vs. Smith Mountain Lake – Which Is Better for Summer?

Virginia’s lake scene offers some of the best summer escapes in the Mid-Atlantic. Among the most talked-about destinations, Lake Anna and Smith Mountain Lake top the list.

Both deliver on water fun, fishing, and relaxing views, but each caters to a different crowd.

For families, anglers, and weekend warriors trying to pick between the two, here’s how they stack up.

Size, Setting & Accessibility

Lake Anna covers roughly 10,000 acres in central Virginia and has become a favorite for quick weekend escapes. Located around 1.5 hours from Washington, D.C., it draws a high volume of visitors due to easy access. The lake is divided into two sections: a public side and a private side.

A nuclear power plant nearby keeps the private side warm throughout the year, which also affects the temperature on the public side, making early spring and late fall swims more enjoyable.

Smith Mountain Lake, located in southwest Virginia, spans about 20,000 acres, offering double the surface area. Set against the backdrop of the Blue Ridge Mountains, it gives off a more scenic and natural impression.

Less touched by suburban sprawl, its atmosphere feels more spaced out and peaceful. Large coves, long stretches of shoreline, and sloping terrain provide visual variation and space for different types of recreation.

Access favors different groups depending on the starting point. Lake Anna works better for residents in Washington, D.C., northern Virginia, and central regions who want minimal time in the car. Interstates and wide roads make it easy to reach.

Smith Mountain Lake, while farther, is still easily reachable for those in Roanoke, Lynchburg, or parts of North Carolina. Drives into the Smith Mountain Lake region tend to be less congested, with more scenic routes and fewer major traffic patterns to navigate.

Fishing Quality & Water Activities

Fishing and water sports play a major role in the summer experience at both lakes.

Choosing the right lake depends largely on comfort level, interest in specific species, and desire for either laid-back recreation or adrenaline-fueled action.

Beginner-Friendly vs. Trophy-Level Fishing

Lake Anna delivers a solid introduction to freshwater fishing, especially for beginners or families with younger anglers. Fish species are abundant and relatively easy to target, making success more likely even without advanced gear or deep knowledge.

The lake is stocked with largemouth bass, striped bass, and hybrid striped bass, providing variety and enough excitement to keep things interesting.

Shallow areas and predictable fish behavior during warmer months help beginners feel confident.

Smith Mountain Lake ranks as one of the top striped bass fisheries in the eastern U.S. Anglers looking for a serious catch will find a more challenging but highly rewarding environment. Trophy-sized striped bass draw seasoned fishermen regularly.

In addition, the lake is home to smallmouth bass, crappie, catfish, and seasonal species. Different depths, underwater structures, and wide-open water demand skill and planning.

• National recognition for striped bass
• Additional species: Smallmouth bass, crappie, channel catfish
• Opportunities for advanced techniques such as trolling and vertical jigging
• Ideal for early-morning and off-season anglers

Recreation Options for Every Type of Water Lover

Water-based fun goes well past casting lines. Lake Anna favors straightforward recreational options that are easy to pick up and enjoy for all skill levels.

Calm coves and warm waters make it safe for young kids and casual paddlers. Equipment rentals for kayaks, paddleboards, and jet skis are widely available near marina zones.

Smith Mountain Lake adds more thrill to its water activities. Deeper water allows for parasailing and wakeboarding, while larger marinas support houseboat rentals.

For those seeking underwater adventure, scuba diving is a popular attraction, with training and gear rentals available on-site.

Summer festivals on the water add to the activity level without overwhelming the serenity.

Lodging & Rentals

A great lake trip often hinges on where you stay. Options range from simple weekend cabins to luxurious waterfront estates, and both lakes deliver different takes on vacation housing. Deciding between the two depends on expectations for comfort, price, availability, and proximity to the water.

Lake Anna offers a wide range of privately owned rentals, mostly made up of modest homes and cabins. Many properties are tucked into residential neighborhoods rather than purpose-built vacation communities.

Weekend stays can be booked with little advance notice during off-peak times, and shorter reservations are often allowed. Travelers who enjoy low-key accommodations will appreciate the down-to-earth feel of the area.

Smith Mountain Lake delivers more variety and scale when it comes to lodging. High-end homes line many coves, and dedicated vacation rental agencies manage a large portion of the offerings. Condos, lakefront estates, and resort-style homes with docks and hot tubs are common.

More developed infrastructure around marinas adds to the convenience for those staying longer or arriving with boats.

Lake Anna may be the better fit for spontaneous or short-stay trips, while Smith Mountain Lake caters more to those looking for higher-end getaways or planning extended stays. Both serve their audiences well, depending on how much space and service are desired.

Local Vibe & Dining

Dining and atmosphere play a big part in how evenings feel after a day on the water. Casual marina eateries suit quick stops, while more established venues offer a polished tone and events. Both destinations deliver distinct experiences worth exploring.

Lake Anna

Local options offer relaxed, family-friendly service and dock‑and‑dine convenience:

• Tim’s at Lake Anna Crabhouse – Waterfront spot open year‑round, indoor/outdoor seating, seafood‑focused menu and live events
• The Cove at Lake Anna – Dock‑accessible restaurant with bar, stage for live music and kid‑friendly options
• Asian Café (Lake Anna Plaza) – Sushi, hibachi, vegetarian selections; easy boat‑in access
• Callie Opie’s Orchard – Farm‑to‑table style in a barn setting; live jazz evenings and pet‑friendly patio
• Breweries & winery stops like Everly Vineyards and Brewing Co., Log Home Brewing Co. offer craft options without needing to head off‑site

Trend favors relaxed, comfortable spots, ideal after long lake days. Atmosphere stays casual, especially off-peak.

Smith Mountain Lake

More refined restaurant scene with waterfront venues, events, and variety:

• The Landing (Mariners Landing Resort) – Fresh local ingredients, French‑American menu, waterfront patio seating
• Bruno’s Clubhouse Bistro, Bottles & Bites – On‑site sister restaurants offering casual to upscale choices, all part of Mariners Landing
• Jake’s Place – Over‑water patio, live music, brick‑oven pizza and hearty fare
• Beacon Seafood Pub & Portside Grill – Fresh seafood, pub fare, lakeside views next to each other at Harbor Trail
• Casa D’Amici, Downtown Pizzeria, Edo Grill and Sushi – Italian, pizza, sushi options for varied tastes

Off‑water casual venues include Drifter’s, Hot Shots, Lumpkins Marina Grill, and Old Oak Café, great for drinks, family meals, and local flavor

Which Is Better for You?

So it comes down to this.